just to feed the fire a little bit, let me tell you what I learned in my "Intro to Teaching" class (before I decided I didn't want to become a teacher).
Turns out that most of the propaganda claiming that our schools are totally broken is media hype (what isn't?). It's easy to sell hype, I guess. And many people buy it: I suppose it's easy to assume that the media tells the truth all the time

. Actually, it's easy to assume that things are terrible elsewhere, especially when you can't see them yourself. Now this isn't to say that there aren't any bad schools out there, but overall, the picture isn't bad.
Essentially, a poll was taken across the USA to determine how parents would rank public schools. The answering was restricted parents that had children in the school system, and they had to give the grade to the school which their oldest child attended. In addition, they would (generally) rate the competing schools in the neighborhood, statewide, and countrywide.
The average across the nation was somewhere between an A and a B for most schools that were attended. But when people were required to rate the nation's schools, they rated B to D. In other words, most people like their schools, but they have a perception that the nation's schools are all broken. If anyone wants, I can give better details when I am not at work.
In any case, you also have to look at it thus: whatever you think about public schools, our Universities are among the top worldwide: nobody can argue that. And how do the students do that come from our "broken" public school system and attend the "world class" university? Just fine, in the end
Of course, that whole last bit disregards the part where many high schoolers don't go to college, but that's a choice for the most part, not a forced decision.
umm . . guess I am done